For those who don’t know what Anchor or the Leveraged Anchor is – a brief background: Anchor Trades were created to address a common desire, the ability to participate in up markets without being at major risk in down markets. There are a plethora of insurance/annuity products that seek to address this, however such products are often hampered by fees, penalties for cashing out or trading out, and caps on gains. Anchor was created to address those concerns. Originally the plan was to take a long position (such as in SPY or other ETFs) and one hundred percent hedge the position using one year put options. The problem with such an approach is the hedge typically cost between 7%-12% of the total portfolio, which makes it cost prohibitive…unless we can come up with a way to “pay for the hedge.”
Anchor attempts to pay for the hedge by selling calendar put spreads on the theory that short term volatility is priced at a higher premium than long term volatility. By way of a simple example, a one year out at the money put might cost $12.00. Yet that same at the money put only one month out likely cost $2.00. So if you were to hedge your portfolio every month, as opposed to yearly, it would cost twice a much. All other things being equal, you should be able to cover the cost of a long dated put by selling short dated puts. Of course it’s not that easy in practice as the markets don’t stay flat. But that is the basic premise behind Anchor.
Anchor’s primary defect, which was proved over the last 5-10 years of bull markets is that it consistently lags behind the market in up markets. This makes sense as an Anchor portfolio is only 90% long and devotes about 10% to the hedge. That means in the best case, Anchor is going to lag the market 10%. In reality, it typically lags a bit more. In prolonged bull markets, this leads people to abandon the strategy (often near a market crash). So to address the concern, we began looking at how to increase performance in bull markets, without hurting to much in down markets. (There always is a trade off, but the plan is to make it as little as possible).
As discussed in earlier comments on the Leveraged Anchor trade, it carries several benefits that Traditional Anchor and/or simply being long the market does not:
By using deep in the money call positions, as opposed to long stock positions, we are able to gain leverage without having to utilize margin interest. Given the rising interest rate environment we are in, and the high cost of margin interest rates generally, this can lead to significant savings;
When we enter the trade, we look for a long call that has a delta of around 90. As the market falls, delta will shrink. For instance, if SPY were to decline ten percent, our long calls would have declined by less than nine percent. The closer we get to our long strike, the slower this decline;
In the event of very large crashes, we can actually make money.
Losses are capped. In the above example, the maximum loss is 9.5%. This can increase if we keep rolling the short puts throughout the downturn, but in any one “crash,” losses are limited to the ten percentage point mark (in Traditional Anchor this 9.5% max loss in one period is better, coming in at 8.5%). If we apply a momentum filter as well, then the risk of continuingly losing on the short puts declines;
- In larger bull markets, the Leveraged Anchor outperforms both Traditional Anchor and simply being long stock as there is actual leverage being used. Some of this will depend on just how fast the market is rising and how often the long hedge is rolled, but in large bull markets, it should still regularly outperform. In fact, in any one period where the market grows more than 3.5% to 4.0%, the Leveraged Anchor will outperform simply being long SPY. The Leveraged version of Anchor will always outperform Traditional Anchor in any up markets.
This is the thirty day performance of the Leveraged Anchor portfolio entered today, at different possible market prices. Note what starts to happen as SPY continues to decline below the 200 point – the value of the portfolio actions starts increasing again. By SPY 150 the portfolio is back into positive territory – even though the market has declined 40%. In reality, this is unlikely to happen, but if a fifty percent or more market drop were to occur, this would be a great benefit. (Note: this happens with Traditional Anchor as well, just at a slower rate);
The six contracts of SPY gives us control over 600 shares, which at a current price of $249/share, provides control over $149,400 of stock – or right at 1.5x leverage.
BIL is currently yielding right around 2.3 percent after the most recent interest rate increases. Given that almost half of our portfolio is invested in this, that will “goose” the portfolio an extra 1.15% per year. It also provides quite a bit of flexibility to roll the long hedge up, cover losses on the short hedges, or to rebalance the whole portfolio after larger gains.
We’re looking forward to the coming year and continuing to work with everyone at Steady Options.
- Anchor Trades Portfolio Launched
- Defining The Anchor Strategy
- Market Thoughts And Anchor Update
- Leveraged Anchor Is Boosting Performance
- Anchor Trades Strategy Performance
- Revisiting Anchor (Thanks To ORATS Wheel)
- Revisiting Anchor Part 2
- Leveraged Anchor Update