Wow... that was a long time ago. This is what I ultimately settled on:
There are a couple of simple formulas that calculate some of the fields. You can see I have fields for "stock implied volatility" and "implied move" which aren't filled in, I just found that really didn't help or add anything for my analysis. This spreadsheet works great for calendars and straddles, but most other type trades don't really "fit" easily, like the hedged straddles. I actually just write that down and keep up with it during the trade and all adjustments on paper. I re-subscribed to the ONE software in January, and I LOVE it for the way it tracks trades and adjustments, but the most powerful part is the backtesting and modeling you can do. I'm considering using only ONE and abandoning the spreadsheet.