SteadyOptions is an options trading forum where you can find solutions from top options traders. TRY IT FREE!

We’ve all been there… researching options strategies and unable to find the answers we’re looking for. SteadyOptions has your solution.

• "One of the many drawbacks of a credit spread is that it will tie up so much capital."
• “Selling credit spreads is like picking up pennies in front of a steam roller.”
• "Credit spreads are different from debit spreads. One has a low probability of success, the other has a high probability of success."

Same Probability? You Bet!

The link in my tweet pointed to one of my previous articles where I clearly demonstrated that credit spreads are in fact the same as debit spreads if using the same strikes.

I guess that one picture is better than thousand words, so lets try to visualize the concept.

Lets try to construct a RUT credit spread having ~80% probability of success. Using August 2014 expiration and July 10 closing prices, we can do the following trade:

• Sell Aug. 2014 RUT 1210 call
• Buy Aug. 2014 RUT 1220 call

The risk profile looks like this:

As we can see, we get \$185 credit for this trade, our margin is \$815 (\$1,000-185) and maximum gain is 22.7% (185/815). The maximum gain is realized if RUT stays below 1210 by August expiration.

As shown in the chart, the breakeven point is 1211.76 and probability of success 79.5%.

Now lets try to construct the same trade with puts. The trade will be:

• Sell Aug. 2014 RUT 1210 put
• Buy Aug. 2014 RUT 1220 put

The risk profile looks like this:

In this trade, we are paying \$815 and our margin is the same as the debit (\$815). The maximum gain is realized if RUT stays below 1210 by August expiration, in which case the put spread will be worth \$1,000. The maximum gain? 1000-815=185, so 185/815=22.7%, exactly the same as with the credit spread. As shown in the chart, the breakeven point is 1211.76 and probability of success 79.5% - again, exactly the same as with the credit spread.

There might be some practical reasons to prefer one trade over another. In our example, the credit spread is constructed using OTM (Out Of The Money) options, that tend to be more liquid and have tighter bid/ask. So while "theoretical" prices might be the same, in practice you might get better fills (which means better probability of success) with the credit spread. In addition, OTM options don't have assignment risk, while ITM options do. That means that you always have to close the ITM spreads before expiration, while with OTM spreads, you can just let them expire. Of course assignment risk is relevant only to American style options. European style options like RUT, SPX etc. can be exercised only at expiration and don't have assignment risk.

The bottom line:

The trade can be constructed by selling lower strike and buying higher strike. When using calls, we will get a credit. When using puts, we will pay a debit. But if the same strikes are used, this is exactly the same trade. Same risk profile, same maximum gain, same probability of success, same breakeven point.

Complete Portfolio Approach

Diversified Options Strategies

Exclusive Community Forum

High Quality Education

Risk Management, Portfolio Size

Performance based on real fills

Try It Free

Non-directional Options Strategies

Targets 5-7% Monthly Net Return

### Articles

• #### McDonald's, Not A Shelter in the Coming Storm

The amount of time and effort that investors spend assessing the risks versus the potential returns of their portfolio should shift as the economy and markets cycle over time. For example, when an economic recovery finally breaks the grip of a recession, and asset prices and valuations have fallen to average or below-average levels, price and economic risks are greatly diminished.

By Michael Lebowitz,

• 66 views
• #### Risk Depends On Your Time Horizon

Those who are nearing retirement and those who have recently retired represent the majority of my financial planning and investment advisory client base. One of the most common mistakes I hear from these types of individuals is something similar to “I no longer have enough time for the market to come back.”

By Jesse,

• 90 views
• #### Estimating Gamma for Calls or Puts

In a recent article, the details for estimate Delta were explained. This article deals with estimates of Gamma, which is denoted with the Greek symbol Γ. This calculation measures the rate of change in Delta and is summarized in percentage form. It is alternatively called the option’s curvature.

By Michael C. Thomsett,

• 339 views
• #### Why Options Traders Fail?

In the last 8 years, I trained thousands of options traders. I have seen many success stories, but also a lot of failures. There are a lot of reasons why many options traders fail. Here are the most common reasons, courtesy of our good friend and veteran options trader Gavin McMaster

By Kim,

• 763 views
• #### Using ORATS Wheel To Test Entries and Exits

My favorite option strategy backtester is ORATS Wheel, which includes a free trial for those interested. In the Steady Momentum PutWrite Strategy (SMPW), we sell out of the money puts on global equity indexes and ETF’s while holding our collateral in short and intermediate term fixed income ETF’s.

By Jesse,

• 524 views
• #### Estimating Delta for Calls or Puts

Options trading relies on many estimates of value and volatility. Among these, the most useful estimate is Delta. Even knowledgeable options traders might not fully understand the “Greeks” and how they operate, especially with one another. They are directly related and are useful in making comparisons of market risk and volatility.

By Michael C. Thomsett,

• 498 views
• #### Are Covered Calls a ‘Sure Thing?’

Most covered call writers enjoy the regularity and reliability of the position. In the majority of cases, the covered call will be profitable, even when underlying shares are called away. This assumes that the strike is higher than the basis in the underlying, and that the call writer understands the real limitations to the strategy.

By Michael C. Thomsett,

• 852 views
• #### Lessons from Bill Ackman's comeback

Bill Ackman is an American investor, hedge fund manager and philanthropist. He is the founder and CEO of Pershing Square Capital Management, a hedge fund management company. Ackman is considered by some to be a contrarian investor but considers himself an activist investor.

By Kim,

• 1 comment
• 2,006 views
• #### Steady Futures 2019 Performance Analysis

Steady Futures began trading the 50K portfolio in July 2019. It produced a 8.5% return during its 6 months of performance (18.0% annualized). We had three goals when we developed this system. First, we wanted a robust system that benefits from turmoil in the markets.

By RapperT,

• 535 views
• #### SteadyOptions 2019 - Year In Review

2019 marks our 8th year as a public service. It was a good year overall. We closed 151 winners out of 232 trades. Our model portfolio produced 41.7% compounded gain on the whole account based on 10% allocation per trade. We had only two losing months in 2019.

By Kim,

• 855 views

Report Article

## We want to hear from you!

Great explanation...if they were not the same, you could do arbitrage...buy to open a debit spread and sell the same amount of credit spreads, or the other way around.

I tend to like short spreads because if the trend changed and the market moves against me, I can always buy to close the short leg and keep the winning long leg.

##### Share on other sites

They are definitely the same, however is there generally better liquidity on the in the money side, i.e. on the ITM Put Credit Spread versus the OTM Call Debit Spread?

##### Share on other sites

Yes, OTM options tend to gave better liquidity.

##### Share on other sites

Your content will need to be approved by a moderator