SteadyOptions is an options trading forum where you can find solutions from top options traders. TRY IT FREE!

We’ve all been there… researching options strategies and unable to find the answers we’re looking for. SteadyOptions has your solution.

Trading Earnings: A Tale Of Two Strategies


When a fellow Seeking Alpha contributor Kevin O'Brian promised back in September to write an article "on Kim Klaiman's/Steady Options trading approach and why it doesn't work as advertised.", I was pretty excited. I have over 10 years of experience in the stock market. However, unlike Kevin who claims to "know basically all there is to know about options", I'm still learning. I will be learning as long as I breathe.

So despite my 152% ROI in 2012, I really wanted to know why my approach doesn't work. Maybe it was all just a fluke?

 

The article finally came out last week, but it had nothing to do with my trading approach. It was all about my personal history with Kevin which I don't think is much of an interest to our readers. My article is strictly about my trading approach and how it compares with Kevin's.

 

First, let me be very clear: no matter what some "gurus" will tell you, no strategy will work all the time. Mine is no exception. I never claimed that it works under all market conditions, and I never claimed that other strategies won't work and mine is the only right thing to do. There is more than one road to Rome.

 

My approach

 

I described my strategy of trading earnings here and here. The strategy is buying a strangle/straddle or Reverse Iron Condor a few days before earnings and selling it just before earnings are announced (or as soon as the trade produces a sufficient profit). The idea is to take advantage of the rising IV (Implied Volatility) of the options before the earnings.

 

Now, few scenarios are possible.

  1. The IV increase is not enough to offset the negative theta and the stock doesn't move. In this case the trade will probably be a small loser. However, since the theta will be at least partially offset by the rising IV, the loss is likely to be in the 7-10% range. It is very unlikely to lose more than 10-15% on those trades if held 2-5 days, and the maximum risk is around 20-25% (except for some very rare cases).
  2. The IV increase offsets the negative theta and the stock doesn't move. In this case, depending on the size of the IV increase, the gains are likely to be in the 5-20% range. In some rare cases, the IV increase will be dramatic enough to produce 30-40% gains.
  3. The IV goes up followed by the stock movement. This is where the strategy really shines. It could bring few very significant winners, sometimes in the 50-60% range.


What I really like about this strategy is the ability to keep the losses small. The risk/reward is significantly smaller than most other options strategies. Overall, the average gain is in the 10-15% range and the average loss in the 5-10% range. Combined with decent winning ratio of ~60%, the strategy should be a winner in the long term.

 


In some cases, when I think that near term options are overvalued, I might also buy a calendar spread with short options expiring just after earnings.

 

Kevin's approach

 

Kevin also likes to trade earnings non-directionally, but with one significant difference: if the trade doesn't produce significant gains before earnings, it will be held through earnings. In my opinion, this strategy has negative long term expectancy because on average, options tend to be overpriced before earnings and IV collapse after the earnings will cause the trade to lose value - unless the stock moves more than implied by the options prices. I described here why I don't like to hold those trades through earnings.

 

Same is true with calendar spreads - if you hold a calendar spread through earnings, you bet that the stock will not move much. If it does, the loss can be catastrophic, as proved by Kevin's IBM trade.

 

The main problem of holding any trade through earnings is complete lack of predictability. Some trades can produce outstanding gains while others end up with catastrophic losses. If the trade uses short expiration and the stock moves less than "predicted" by the options prices, the collapsed IV will cause a very significant loss.

 

How position sizing impacts the overall performance

 

The most important point that many traders ignore is the position sizing. Even if the second strategy (holding through earnings) produces higher average gains (and I doubt it), what really matters is how much your overall account gains. When you risk only 20-25% per trade worst case, you can easily allocate 10% per trade. However, when you hold through earnings, your risk is up to 90-100%. That means that realistically, you cannot allocate more than 2-3% per trade. If you allocate 10% and you have a streak of 4-5 big losers, you have just lost half of your account. Whoever claims never having such a streak is either lying or hasn't been trading for long enough.

 

Kevin keeps saying that he "doesn't trade options for a 5% ROI". Let's check what 5% return can do to your account.

 

Assuming that you make 20 trades per month, allocate 10% per trade and make 5% per trade, your overall account grows 10% per month. Commissions will reduce it to ~7-8% per month. That's about 80-90% per year, non-compounded (while having ~40% of the account in cash). Increasing the allocation to 15% will produce 120-140% annual return while still risking only 3% per trade. I challenge Kevin to show how he can achieve a similar return with his strategy with similar level of risk. I also challenge him to show any kind of statistics for his strategy of holding through earnings.

 

Here is another point that many traders miss. If you have a 15% loser and two 15% winners, that's 5% average return. But if you take a 100% loser, it will take two 60% winners or three 40% winners to produce similar 5% average return.

 

Conclusion

 

To conclude, it all comes to what kind of trader you want to be. Is your goal to limit the losses or to maximize the gains? You cannot have it both ways. Higher gains come with higher risk and inevitably will produce some big losers, so the position sizing has to be adjusted accordingly. Risk and reward are closely related in trading.

 

 

Start your free trial now

What Is SteadyOptions?

Full Trading Plan

Complete Portfolio Approach

Diversified Options Strategies

Exclusive Community Forum

Steady And Consistent Gains

High Quality Education

Risk Management, Portfolio Size

Performance based on real fills

Try It Free

Non-directional Options Strategies

10-15 trade Ideas Per Month

Targets 5-7% Monthly Net Return

Visit our Education Center

Recent Articles

Articles

  • Things To Think About Before Getting Involved In Investing

    There are various benefits associated with investing. It can be a great way to boost your income, providing you with financial security during a troubling time. Smart investing also comes with the possibility of long-term returns, meaning it can be better to invest your money than leave it in your regular bank account (even if you are earning interest). 

    By Kim,

    • 0 comments
    • 194 views
  • Micron Technology (MU) Earnings Report June 30, 2022

    Welcome to the ORATS earnings report where we scan for companies with upcoming earnings announcements, check out historical earnings information, and find a potential options trade. Read on or watch the video overview here: https://youtu.be/IDgR3FzONnI.

    By ORATS_Matt,

    • 0 comments
    • 224 views
  • Does “Managing Winners” Add Value to Short Strangles?

    Some option educators suggest short strangles have historically benefited from actively managed exit strategies. A widely popularized approach is to enter S&P 500 strangles at 45 DTE and exit at 50% of the credit received or a 21 DTE time stop, whichever occurs first.

    By Jesse,

    • 2 comments
    • 4,702 views
  • NKE Earnings Report June 27, 2022

    Welcome to the ORATS earnings report where we scan for companies with upcoming earnings announcements, check out historical earnings information, and find a potential options trade. Read on or watch the video overview here: https://youtu.be/2mtx2ja-VwQ.

    By ORATS_Matt,

    • 0 comments
    • 233 views
  • KBH Earnings Report June 22, 2022

    Welcome to the ORATS earnings report where we scan for companies with upcoming earnings announcements, check out historical earnings information, and find a potential options trade.

    Read on or watch here:

    By ORATS_Matt,

    • 0 comments
    • 298 views
  • Know How To Trade Before Making An Investment

    Everyone is searching for a way to improve their living quality. Plenty of scopes are coming to the forefront and people are grabbing the opportunities with the hope of receiving the best revenue against their investment. A share market is a place that can return the high revenue of your investment.

    By Kim,

    • 0 comments
    • 320 views
  • Implied Volatility and Standard Deviation

    1. Isn't holding a naked long call (as a result of locking in a profit or plain buying outright call) in general a bad idea? Reason I think so is because of the nature of IV: it mostly falls when the underlying is rising. So you have short theta and a big long vega moving against you.

    By Mark Wolfinger,

    • 0 comments
    • 299 views
  • Introducing a "Risk Free" Trade

    A few weeks ago, I got the following email from one of our former members: "I would like to share with you an article about "projected no risk trades" or "no risk trades". Of course I was skeptical. But when he shared the setup with me, I became intrigued. How does the following risk profile look to you?

    By Kim,

    • 6 comments
    • 1,392 views
  • What You Trade Matters

    Traders love to tell people that they can trade anything. That if you have the skills to be a trader, the specific item traded is unimportant. That may be true for some professional traders who are skilled technicians. However, it’s very different for gullible amateurs.

    By Mark Wolfinger,

    • 0 comments
    • 633 views
  • The Big Loss

    At his blog, Joey offers his perspective on the top reason that so many trader wannabes are not, and will not, become profitable traders. His post is titled: Learn to Lose Money to Make Money. Here are the Excerpts from the blog.

    By Mark Wolfinger,

    • 0 comments
    • 822 views

  Report Article

We want to hear from you!


Kim:


 


Help me out here.  I believe I read your response to Kevin O'Brien on calendar spreads.  I think you said using it during earnings was a bad idea.  I am trying to understand why.  If the front month has a high volatility, and the later month has a lower vol, after earnings is announced, the front month vol should drop.  Since I sold that option, that should be good. But in trying different double calendar spreads, I notice that despite this drop in vol, the trades are not always profitable.  It could be that the stock moves out of the breakeven points.  But conceptually, why is the calendar spread a bad idea during earnings?  Or is there a way to structure a calendar spread that would better position to profit during earnings? Thanks.


tradervic

Share this comment


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Holding calendars through earnings is not always a bad idea. In fact, since short term options are on average overpriced, those trades have a good chance to make money in the long term.

 

The biggest problem is lack of predictability. Like I mentioned in the article, some trades can produce outstanding gains while others end up with catastrophic losses. As you mentioned, if the stock moves outside the profit zone, the loss can be very substantial. Unlike "standard" calendars where you can control the risk in most cases, if the stock gaps after earnings and doesn't reverse, there is nothing you can do to limit the loss.

 

So the key is:

1. Reduce position sizing to account for a big loss.

2. Select stocks with favorable risk/reward based on historical moves. For example, doing those trades on a stock like NFLX is a VERY BAD idea. In the last 8 cycles, the NFLX calendar held through earnings was a consistent loser.

Share this comment


Link to comment
Share on other sites


Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account. It's easy and free!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now

Options Trading Blogs Expertido