SteadyOptions is an options trading forum where you can find solutions from top options traders. TRY IT FREE!

We’ve all been there… researching options strategies and unable to find the answers we’re looking for. SteadyOptions has your solution.

# Should You Finance or Pay Cash for a Home?

When buying a home, individuals who have accumulated enough wealth to pay cash or make a substantial down payment have a decision to make. Take advantage of record low interest rates and lock in a 30-year mortgage for around 2.5%? Or pay cash and make payments to yourself by investing the savings?

If an individual were to borrow \$300,000 with a 30-year fixed rate mortgage at 2.5% they would have a payment of \$1,185.36/month. Assuming the \$300,000 was invested in a brokerage account, a systematic withdrawal strategy could be established to make the payments directly from the account. If the individual instead were to pay cash, they could systematically invest the \$1,185.36/month in a brokerage account.

Which approach would produce the better financial outcome over 30 years? To answer this question, let’s turn to the data from 1990-2019, which is the last 30 calendar years. We’ll assume the investment used is a globally diversified equity index from Dimensional Fund Advisors.

Finance with 30 yr mortgage: \$1,185.36/monthly payment made from \$300,000 fully invested brokerage account. Account value at the end of 2019: \$3,556,328

Pay cash and invest the payment: Invest \$1,185.36/month into the equity index every month from 1990-2019. Account value at the end of 2019: \$2,640,176

The last 30 years are one investment path traveled that is likely to be different over the next 30 years. In order to estimate different potential outcomes over the next 30 years, we can use Monte Carlo simulation. This technique takes the monthly returns from the 1990-2019 data set but reorders them to create 10,000 different simulations of potential 30-year outcomes. To illustrate the concept, imagine each monthly return is a ball in a bucket. You draw out a ball and write down the number. You then put the ball back in the bucket and take out another until you come up with 30 year’s worth of monthly returns. You then repeat this process 10,000 times and analyze the data.

Finance with 30 year mortgage: \$1,185.36/monthly payment made from \$300,000 fully invested brokerage account. Potential results after 30 years.

• 5th percentile: \$39,070
• 25th percentile: \$1,356,445
• 50th percentile: \$3,506,039
• 75th percentile: \$7,545,503
• 95th percentile: \$19,611,719

Pay cash and invest the payment: Invest \$1,185.36/month into the equity index every month from 1990-2019. Potential results after 30 years.

• 5th percentile: \$842,846
• 25th percentile: \$1,785,961
• 50th percentile: \$2,966,124
• 75th percentile: \$4,876,722
• 95th percentile: \$9,565,885

This may lead an individual to different conclusions than only looking at the last 30 years of realized results. Note how the 5th and 95th percentile outcomes are vastly different, and if we consider the 50th percentile the expected value it favors the borrowing strategy. Someone with less tolerance for risk would prefer to pay cash and invest the equivalent of the mortgage payment, whereas someone with greater risk tolerance may be willing to take on the mortgage debt.

Taxes are an additional variable that should be considered. If someone was taking the standard deduction, they may prefer to pay cash as mortgage interest would not be deductible. They may also be able to make the monthly investment into a tax advantaged account such as a Roth IRA or 401(k) where growth would accumulate tax free. Looking at this data, I personally lean towards paying cash or making a substantial down payment and investing the payment. There is value associated with the peace of mind in knowing you have little or no debt and therefore no risk of lower than expected investment returns or a bad sequence of returns. What do you think? Feel free to share in the comments section below!

Jesse Blom is a licensed investment advisor and Vice President of Lorintine Capital, LP. He provides investment advice to clients all over the United States and around the world. Jesse has been in financial services since 2008 and is a CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™ professional. Working with a CFP® professional represents the highest standard of financial planning advice. Jesse has a Bachelor of Science in Finance from Oral Roberts University.

Complete Portfolio Approach

Diversified Options Strategies

Exclusive Community Forum

High Quality Education

Risk Management, Portfolio Size

Performance based on real fills

Try It Free

Non-directional Options Strategies

Targets 5-7% Monthly Net Return

### Articles

• #### Tax Efficient Trading Part II: Capital Gains Deferral

In part I I illustrated how the preferential tax treatment of 1256 contracts could improve after tax returns of a PutWrite strategy over a long period of time. In this article, I’ll continue the illustration by switching from a PutWrite to an ETF BuyWrite (covered calls) strategy while holding pre-tax expected returns constant at 8%.

By Jesse,

• 523 views
• #### Tax Efficient Trading Part I: The 1256 Contracts

Cash settled index options like SPX, XSP, RUT and a few others receive special federal tax treatment where 60% of the gains are reported as a Long Term Capital Gain (LTCG) even if the contract was held for less than a year.

By Jesse,

• 462 views
• #### SPY Short Puts vs. Put Spreads

In this article I’ll be using the ORATS Wheel backtesting tool to compare the performance since 2007 of SPY short puts versus short put spreads. I’ll look at both risk and returns, and different ways of determining position size to adjust for the differences in risk between the two trades.

By Jesse,

• 1 comment
• 1,098 views
• #### Signs that you Are Ready to Start Investing

If you want to build your wealth, you have to make sure that you invest your money. If you put money into a savings account and don’t earn any interest from it, this won’t work for you in the long term. Your money will lose value because of inflation, and this is the last thing that you need. So when do you invest?

By Kim,

• 659 views
• #### One Year of Diversified leveraged Anchor

I almost hate to keep saying it, but the Diversified Leveraged Anchor strategy keeps exceeding expectations and performing as designed. To remind our readers, Diversified Leveraged Anchor was created in April 2020 attempting to further increase performance, reduce risk, and to reduce volatility.

By cwelsh,

• 1,587 views
• #### Should I Pay Off My Mortgage Early Or Invest?

Paying off a home mortgage early is a popular financial goal. Most people feel a level financial peace when their home is paid off that is beneficial in many ways. The most common approach to paying off the mortgage early is directly making additional principal payments to the lender on a regular basis.

By Jesse,

• 666 views
• #### Option Order Execution Tips

As a community of option traders, we all can relate to the occasional challenges of order execution. Best practices for avoiding errors as well as techniques for better potential execution will be the focus of this article.  Like countless others in the Steady Options community, I personally have traded thousands of option contracts over the last decade.

By Jesse,

• 2,204 views
• #### What Trading Can Offer To A Newcomer

For any first-time investor, one of the most important questions to ask is “why are you doing this?”. Getting into investment can be thrilling and open up new worlds for you, but it can also be draining both physically and emotionally, with long days and sudden market moves always a genuine risk.

By Kim,

• 897 views
• #### Updated: The Performance Gap Between Large Growth and Small Value Stocks

Eight months ago on July 21st 2020 I posted an article, The Performance Gap Between Large Growth and Small Value Stocks. Over the long-term small cap value stocks have outperformed large cap growth stocks, although not over more recent history.

By Jesse,

• 1,426 views
• #### 6 Ways to Invest Your Money That Aren't Cash Savings

It’s always a good idea to keep some of your money in cash so if there is an emergency and you need money in a hurry, you can access it without having to worry. However, cash savings are not your only option if you have money left over at the end of the month, and there are a lot of other options that could bring greater returns.

By Kim,

• 1,116 views

Report Article

## We want to hear from you!

There are no comments to display.

## Create an account

Register a new account