SteadyOptions is an options trading forum where you can find solutions from top options traders. TRY IT FREE!

We’ve all been there… researching options strategies and unable to find the answers we’re looking for. SteadyOptions has your solution.

Index Options or ETF Options?


I'm asked many times which product is better to trade: Index options or ETF options? Is IWM better than RUT? Is SPX better than SPY? There is no simple answer to that question. If one product was superior to other, the other would not be trading anymore. There are pros and cons to each product, and this article describes different aspects of trading Index options vs. ETF options.

The Index and the Index-based ETF
 

The starting place is understanding the differences between an Index and an Index-based ETF. Indices are numerical calculations and have no physical existence (sort of like digital currency). On the other hand, one can replicate an index by buying the components that make up the Index. That's what Index-based ETFs such as SPY do. The ETF buys the underlying stocks in the proportions necessary to mimic the associated index. One can buy or sell an ETF. One cannot buy or sell an Index.

So, let's look at the major indices (most popular) and the ETFs that replicate them. Other Indices and ETFs exist, but they are more thinly traded and present some nuance beyond the scope of this article.
 

94491-15180115783732688.png

 

One way to indirectly invest in an index is to invest in an ETF that corresponds to the index. However, though one can't directly invest in an Index, they can trade options on it.

 

Settlement

 

SPY, DIA, QQQ and IWM are ETFs and their options are American style. Both the last trading day and expiration day for these options are the same: the third Friday of the month just like options on individual stocks.

SPX, DJX, NDX, and RUT are indexes and their options are Index Options. They are European Style options, which means that their monthly “last trading day” is different than those of ETFs. Index options expire on the third Friday of the month, so their last trading day is the third Thursday of the month.

 

If you are not familiar with the important differences between these option styles, check out this post. I recommend NEVER holding RUT options into settlement Friday to avoid settlement risk.

 

Assignment Risk
 

Some investors use call or put spreads in IRAs. Some use bull spreads and some bear spreads. Whether they are calls or puts, bull or bear, one leg is always "short" and susceptible to assignment. This possibility is magnified around the ex-dividend date.

 

The short call assignment: If the investor used a call spread and the short leg is assigned ... well, "Houston We Have a Problem". IRAs do not permit the short sale of stock, and if a short call is assigned one must immediately cover the short. Well one can't cover a short unless one has cash available to execute a closing buy of the short. If ready cash isn't sufficient it will necessitate selling other holdings. If there isn't sufficient cash under any circumstance they jeopardize the tax deferral of the entire IRA. If you've ever encountered this, you know what a mess it is. ETF options run that risk, index options do not. BIG difference.


If one is using call spreads in an IRA it practically mandates using SPX, not SPY.


The short put assignment: Unlike naked shorts, naked puts are permitted in IRAs provided there is sufficient cash on hand to cover an assignment (cash secured puts). So that problem is self-remedied. However, if one is using put spreads and not cash secured puts, they run the risk of being assigned without sufficient cash to cover the assignment. So, cash-secured-puts can use SPY options, while put spreads should consider SPX.


Covered calls: There's the counterpart to "assignment" ... getting "called away". In this situation, one owns SPY and sells a covered call. Well, if the call goes ITM, one risks it being exercised and SPY is automatically liquidated. This isn't the technical problem resultant from spreads, but it can be an inconvenience. Additionally, one would incur cost to reinstitute the position. They might even have to reinstitute at a higher price. SPX options would just make the cash adjustment.


What most investors don't know is that the CBOE allows one to pair Index options with it's corresponding ETF. So one isn't restricted to pairing SPY options with SPY, but can sell covered calls using SPX. Some broker-dealers may not permit this, so check with your broker. Just because the CBOE allows it, doesn't mean the BD has the capability of allowing it.


Image result for spx spy options
 

Liquidity

 

SPY has very "tight" bid/ask spreads. This helps planning because one has a pretty could idea of the execution price. It also enables the use of market orders which are easier and can execute much quicker than limit orders. When using market orders, many brokers (I know Fidelity does) offer price improvements that can result in favorable execution prices.


SPX, on the other hand, has a relatively wide bid/ask spread when compared to SPY. This means that limit orders are a must. That means some "bargaining" with the price and much slower execution. It is more time intensive, less precise and one never really knows if they received the best price.
 

 

Some traders prefer ETFs like SPY or IWM due to better liquidity. What they often forget is the fact that Index options are 10 times bigger product, so 20 cents spread on RUT is equivalent to 2 cents spread on IWM. For example, spread of 10.00/10.50 on RUT would be equivalent to 1.00/1.05 on IWM. The slippage on RUT is usually no more than 10-15 cents which is 1-1.5 cents on IWM.

 

Position size

 

There are differences in size of the contracts. For example, the SPY is 1/10 the size of the SPX and the IWM is 1/10 the size of the RUT. To build the same dollar amount position, you will need to buy 10 times more contracts on IWM than on RUT. That means you will need 10 contracts of IWM for every one RUT option to have the same profit potential. But small traders may not want to trade as much as a one-lot in RUT, and can invest smaller sums by trading a few contracts of IWM.

 

Commissions

 

Buying less contracts means a significant difference in commissions. For example: if you buy one lot of 10 strike RUT Iron Condor, you will trade 8 round trip contracts. At $1/contract, that's $8 or 0.8% of the $1,000 margin. Buy 10 lots of 1 strike IWM Iron Condor - and the commissions jump to $80 or 8% of the $1,000 margin.

 

Tax Treatment Differences

 

Here there is a substantial plus to Index options. The IRS treats these indexes differently from stocks (or ETFs).

 

The Index options get special Section 1256 treatment which enables the investor to have 60% of a gain as long term (at a 15% tax rate), and the other 40% treated as short term (at the regular 35% short term capital gains rate) even if the position is held for less than a year.

 

By contrast, the ETFs are treated as ordinary stocks, and thus if held less than a year, all gains are taxed at the less favorable 35% short-term capital gains rate.

 

Thus the Index options can be better from a tax standpoint. You should of course consult with your tax advisor to see how these tax implications may or may not be significant in your situation.

Verdict: SPX tax treatment is significantly better than SPY. SPY has an advantage in LEAPS, but from a practical point of view, it can't even come close to the advantages offered SPX. Remember, it's not what you make it's what you keep that matters.

 

Summary

 

There are many factors to consider in choosing SPY options versus SPX options. Each has their advantages and shortcomings.

 

SPX clearly wins the "assignment risk" war and the "taxable account" war. It loses on flexibility, convenience and trading costs.
 

For those that trade options in IRAs and ROTHs, SPX should be very seriously considered. Sometimes it's better to pay a little and NOT be sitting on a time-bomb.


For those with taxable accounts the tax advantages afforded SPX dwarfs any increase in costs. In the end it comes down to one's willingness to spend extra time and effort to achieve tax savings..


For me, the choice is clear: I prefer RUT over IWM and SPX over SPY. But it might be different for you, as you might have a different commissions structure, different tax treatment, prefer smaller size trades etc.

What Is SteadyOptions?

Full Trading Plan

Complete Portfolio Approach

Diversified Options Strategies

Exclusive Community Forum

Steady And Consistent Gains

High Quality Education

Risk Management, Portfolio Size

Performance based on real fills

Try It Free

Non-directional Options Strategies

10-15 trade Ideas Per Month

Targets 5-7% Monthly Net Return

Visit our Education Center

Recent Articles

Articles

  • A Global Equity Put Write Portfolio

    Many that sell equity market put options focus on the S&P 500 (SPX, XSP, SPY). Some will add small caps by selling puts on the Russell 2000 (RUT, IWM). An investor could also make their put selling strategy globally diversified by adding MSCI EAFE (EFA) and Emerging Markets (EEM).

    By Jesse,

    • 0 comments
    • 200 views
  • The Random Walk Hypothesis

    The “random walk hypothesis” (RWH) is one idea about how stock prices behave – but only one of many. It is a theory promoted in academia and believed in my many, but not so much by traders involved with handling real money. Theories aside, is the market truly random?

    By Michael C. Thomsett,

    • 0 comments
    • 279 views
  • How To Trade Options Successfully

    I’ve now been trading options for over a decade and been associated with Steady Options for seven years – hard to believe.  Over that period, I’ve learned quite a bit about option trading; how to improve, what not to do, and generally how the option markets work. I’m still learning.

    By cwelsh,

    • 3 comments
    • 528 views
  • January 2019 Performance Analysis

    No one likes losing money, and no one likes hearing "excuses". However, in an effort to be fully transparent, solicit feedback, and to improve our own performance, we're writing this article to do a further breakdown of the losses which our model portfolio incurred in January 2019. 

    By Kim,

    • 17 comments
    • 1,322 views
  • Island Clusters as Strong Reversals

    Options traders constantly seek the elusive reliable reversal signal. A few unusual but strong reversals are worth looking for, and their patterns reveal likely exceptional timing for opening or closing option trades. One example of this exceptionally strong signal is the island cluster (or, island reversal).

    By Michael C. Thomsett,

    • 0 comments
    • 357 views
  • What’s Wrong With Your 401(k)? (If anything)

    There currently are over sixty million Americans that are active 401(k) participants, and well over 500,000 total active 401(k) plans offered by employers in the United States.  Despite these high numbers, usages could be higher, as the US Census Bureau estimates that only 41% of all employees with access to a 401(k) plan utilize it, with even less funding it fully.

    By cwelsh,

    • 0 comments
    • 439 views
  • Upcoming Decay of Options

    I am on the hunt for a short volatility position for three main reasons. First, the market’s wild swings have, for the time being at least, diminished. Second, option activity has dried up as my options barometer continues to be stuck in the 4 – 6 range as traders are not making big bets in either direction.

    By Jacob Mintz,

    • 0 comments
    • 521 views
  • The Scientific Process of Increasing Expected Returns

    For many US investors, the "base case" for equity investing is US large cap stocks, most commonly benchmarked as the S&P 500. You could absolutely do far worse than owning these 500 great US companies, and the weight of the evidence suggests that most actively managed mutual funds that benchmark themselves against the S&P 500 index have in fact done worse.

    By Jesse,

    • 0 comments
    • 906 views
  • Those Golden and Death Crosses

    The use of moving average (MA) for predicting future price behavior must be undertaken cautiously. MA is a lagging indicator, so the question must be: Can a lagging indicator provide guidance for the future? Yes. The use of two MA lines and how they interact is a reliable form of reversal indicator.

    By Michael C. Thomsett,

    • 0 comments
    • 633 views
  • Trading Reverse Iron Condors When IV Is Elevated

    Our members know that pre earnings straddles and calendars have been our bread and butter strategies in the recent years. We enter those trades when the prices are cheap compared to previous cycles. However, in the last few months of 2018, Implied Volatility exploded, making most of those trades too expensive.

    By Kim,

    • 0 comments
    • 706 views

  Report Article

We want to hear from you!


Kim:

 

It also should be mentioned, regarding tax implications, that ETFs are also subject to the nasty "Wash Sales Rule" which can be a pain to deal with at the end of the calendar year. If some of your subscribers are not familiar with this "Rule", they can find details available on the internet by simply looking up "Tax Wash Sales Rule".

 

DVK

Share this comment


Link to comment
Share on other sites

What's also noteworthy, some ETFs pay dividend. If you possess short ETF calls (e.g. SPY or IWM) - also as a part of a spread or butterfly - with monthly expiration in March, June, September and December (dividend months), you risk to be assigned already weeks before expiration day. I know this can theoretically always happen but the probability to be assigned in these months is X times higher. Except that you suddenly find short stocks in your account, you also have to pay the dividend (for 100 shares per option lot) to the option buyer. It happened to me once and I wouldn't want to experience it again. Since then, whenever possible I always would use index or future options instead of ETFs.

Share this comment


Link to comment
Share on other sites


Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account. It's easy and free!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now

Options Trading Blogs