SteadyOptions is an options trading forum where you can find solutions from top options traders. Join Us!

We’ve all been there… researching options strategies and unable to find the answers we’re looking for. SteadyOptions has your solution.

Fat Tails and Option Returns

When it comes to calculating likely returns from option activity, traders contend with a variety of variations. Returns may be skewed (with declines in value more likely than increases), or unstable in many forms. Or the outcome might reveal itself in the form of a fat tail.


Fat tails can be graphed to show that tails are greater than normal distribution. On the well-known bell curve, probability of outcomes are most likely to occur at mid-range, with less likelihood in the tails, which are even on both sides. A fat tail graph shows that either declines or increases are higher than the expectation of this curve.

These fatter probability masses throw the entire theory into chaos, but it also reflects what often turns out to be the reality. It is comforting to believe that normal distribution will occur, but while it is likely, it is not always the case.

A fat tail may be subtle but important. The degree of change from normal distribution might be small, but in terms of net returns, it can significantly affect outcomes of trades. For example, the illustration shows how a set of fail tail distributions might appear. The normal distribution would be even on both sides, declining as the tails expand. In the fat tail version, the outcome reveals larger than normal losses (on the left) compared to normal profit distribution (on the right).


From the point of view of risk analysis, this type of distribution can help in identifying likely volatility on one side or the other. Volatility is best understood as the likely degree of change, but it does not identify whether that degree is going to increase or decrease price. It does identify the risk of change. Based on historical data for a particular underlying and its historical volatility, traders can equate fat tail analysis to likely option performance. Of course, this is all based on estimates of future volatility derived from the past.

A detailed analysis of how fat tail graphing works out in the real world would require many examples, and most traders do not have the automated tools to perform such detailed studies. It also raises the question of whether analysis of past price behavior is instructive enough to indicate a smart trade choice. In fact, it cannot be the case, because the past is only one pattern, but price distribution can take many forms and will be based on many, many factors. The occurrence of fat tails is more realistic than standard deviation, assuming a trader can rely on the proper side of the graph (positive or negative) and on whether all the mitigating factors are known and understood (they cannot be because there are potentially so many, and they do not apply in every situation).

An example of the unreliability of fat tail calculation can be found in analysis of earnings surprises. Traders are known to time trades based on assumptions about (a) whether surprises will occur and in which direction, (b) how large the difference will be between expected and actual earnings, and (c) the level of reaction for underlying and option prices.

Given the possibility that ‘a’ and ‘b’ are correctly estimated, the effect of ‘c’ cannot be known. An underlying security might experience identical earnings surprises in two consecutive quarters, both positive, and both about 10% above estimates. Even so, the underlying and option changes are different in each case. In the first of the two quarters, the underlying gains 6 points; in the second, it loses 2 points.

These differences occur for an infinite number of reasons. Investor and trader perception of value might have changed between the two periods. Management guidance about the coming year might be dissimilar as well. And finally, an unknown number of outside causes affect price in any given moment, so it is not realistic to expect the underlying or the options to behave in a similar manner.

In a perfect world, the distribution of returns would predict how option premium would change as the result of an earnings surprise. In the real world, this is not possible or reliable. Traders constantly seek some form of reassurance that with the right statistical tools and analysis, trade profits can be improved consistently. Everyone who has been trading for even a few months knows that this is not realistic. Too many factors are in play.

A bell curve for expected price behavior at the time of earnings reports could reflect how prices might respond to degrees of earnings surprises. This could be a revealing exercise, if a trader correctly predicts the degree of surprise and the direction (positive or negative). The normal distribution of the bell curve could then predict likely option premium reactions to the plotted level of surprise. However, many additional factors beyond the underlying will influence the reliability of this. These factors include bid/ask spread, time remaining to expiration for each option contract, moneyness of the strike selected, open interest, delta and gamma, and that “unknown” factor that causes some options to behave predictably, and others to reveal fat tail behavior.

The use of bell curves with either normal distribution or fat tails is also limited in usefulness. For studies of finite possible outcomes (such as whether a consumer will but product A, B or C), the study of distribution is reliable. For the analysis of option returns, there are simply too many possibilities, making it an infinite range of possibilities. In fact, analysis could even reveal that just about every option return will be found to have fat tails, because “normal” distribution is too vague to be applied with confidence.

In summary, when the outcomes are infinite (or at least appear to be), the fat tail analysis is not going to reveal much beyond guesswork. Some traders are infatuated with statistical analysis using fat tails and expected returns, but it simply is not possible to develop a consistent or reliable result. Even if you know in advance the exact direction and degree of an earnings surprise, there are still enough variables in play to make the probability analysis a poor method for picking and timing trades.

Michael C. Thomsett is a widely published author with over 80 business and investing books, including the best-selling Getting Started in Options, coming out in its 10th edition later this year. He also wrote the recently released The Mathematics of Options. Thomsett is a frequent speaker at trade shows and blogs on his website at Thomsett Publishing as well as on Seeking Alpha, LinkedIn, Twitter and Facebook.


What Is SteadyOptions?

Full Trading Plan

Complete Portfolio Approach

Diversified Options Strategies

Exclusive Community Forum

Steady And Consistent Gains

High Quality Education

Risk Management, Portfolio Size

Performance based on real fills


Non-directional Options Strategies

10-15 trade Ideas Per Month

Targets 5-7% Monthly Net Return

Visit our Education Center

Recent Articles


  • The Importance  of Proactive Hedging in Options Trading

    Investing in the stock market can be a daunting task for even the most experienced investors. With the constant fluctuations and volatility of the market, it can be difficult to predict the future direction of the market. This is where options trading comes into play.

    By Karl Domm,

  • The Silent Bank Run

    Long before Silicon Valley Bank failed, the banking sector was experiencing a silent bank run. Unlike the Great Depression, where lines of people clamoring for their money were blocks long, this silent bank run, as its name portends, has been out of sight until recently. There are a couple of reasons for this. 

    By Michael Lebowitz,

  • The 10 Best Options Trading Books

    Options trading can be challenging. I look at it as a journey, a long term investment, which is no different that graduating from University. And like University, you need to do a lot of reading, along with a lot of practicing. Fortunately, there are a lot of books out there that can be of tremendous help in this journey.

    By Kim,

  • OptionNET Explorer (ONE) Software

    OptionNET Explorer (ONE) is a complete options trading and analysis software platform that enables the user to backtest complex options trading strategies, analyze their results and monitor them in real-time, all from within a single, user friendly environment. 

    By Kim,

  • What Happened to SFO Magazine (SFOMag)? Stocks, Options and Futures Magazine

    Remember SFO Magazine? Traders like Jack Schwager and Brett Steenbarger used to write for the publication before its swift shutdown in 2012. What happened. SFO (Stocks, Futures, and Options) magazine was a monthly financial magazine focused on trading and investing in stocks, futures, and options markets.

    By Pat Crawley,

  • How to Use the Finest Covered Call Strategy

    Investing in the stock market can be a great way to grow your wealth over time. However, it can also be a volatile and unpredictable place, with sudden swings in stock prices causing anxiety for even the most experienced investors. This is where the covered call strategy comes in - a popular options trading strategy that can help manage portfolio volatility.

    By Kim,

  • Put/Call Parity

    Put/call parity is a crucial concept in options trading that establishes the basics of option pricing. The formula, introduced in 1969, came years before the seminal Black-Scholes pricing model. As such, it was one of the first formulations of quantitative option pricing and served as the foundation for future pioneers like Black, Merton, and Scholes.

    By Pat Crawley,

  • What Are Cash-Settled Options?

    Options are finite, wasting assets. They have a shelf-life, and they cease to exist after their expiration. So when that expiration date comes, there needs to be a mechanism in place to ensure that both sides of an option contract hold up their side of the bargain.

    By Pat Crawley,

  • Everything You Need to Know About Options Assignment Risk

    The fear of being assigned early on a short option position is enough to cripple many would-be options traders into sticking by their tried-and-true habit of simply buying puts or calls. After all, theoretically, the counterparty to your short options trade could exercise the option at any time, potentially triggering a Margin Call on your account if you’re undercapitalized.

    By Pat Crawley,

  • Index Options vs. Stock Options: What's The Difference?

    Most traders get their start with options in stock options. Perhaps they want to bet on a big move in a stock or hedge a long stock position. However, there’s more to the world of options than simply stock options, Index Options, which are options listed for indexes like the S&P 500 index or Nasdaq 100 index.

    By Pat Crawley,


  Report Article

We want to hear from you!

There are no comments to display.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account. It's easy and free!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Options Trading Blogs Expertido