On the "liberation day" crash, we just barely missed what I would have considered to be our roll point for the hedges. On that day, S&P was down about 17% and my portfolio was down about 10%. We didn't quite hit the roll point, so now we've sort of inverted with the S&P being down about 6% while my portfolio is down about 11%. But if we continue to recover, portfolio should recover faster here. If we retest lows, we should be able to roll this time and lock in being ahead. If we just float right here, we should be able to make pretty good premium on our diagonals, but I would assume we would lag the market a bit.
Had the price of SPY dropped about another $10, we likely would have rolled our hedges and been up. Sometimes we just don't quite hit the break point though.